PrimeEyes Glide vs LushLine+: Which Eyeliner Is Better for Mature Eyes?
Considering the PrimeEyes Glide Eyeliner by Prime Prometics? We put this Prime eyeliner head-to-head with LushLine+ by Rumi Cosmetiques in an honest, side-by-side review for mature eyes.
Researched by the team of Cosmetic Scientists & Beauty Specialists. We bought both eyeliners at full retail and tested them over 12 real-world days, with no brand paying for placement. This independent Prime Prometics eyeliner review puts the PrimeEyes Glide eyeliner against our top pick for mature eyes.
Both are made for mature eyes — but only one stayed put all day
PrimeEyes Glide is a genuinely good, gentle liner with a beautiful shade range. But in every wear test, LushLine+ lasted longer than the Prime glide eyeliner, resisted water rather than just splashes, and cost less — making it our overall pick for everyday wear.
Where each eyeliner wins
We're not here to pretend the PrimeEyes Glide eyeliner is a bad product — it isn't. Here's an honest look at how the Prime Prometics glide eyeliner and LushLine+ compare, category by category.
All-day wear & waterproofing
PrimeEyes is water-resistant — it holds up to splashes and light moisture, but on watery or oily lids we saw softening by late afternoon. LushLine+ is genuinely waterproof: it held through the gym and a hot shower with no transfer to the crease.
LushLine+ winsComfort on mature & hooded lids
Both glide on without dragging crepey skin, which is exactly what mature eyes need. PrimeEyes is ophthalmologist tested; LushLine+ conditions as it defines. This one is genuinely close.
A close drawApplication & tools
PrimeEyes includes a handy pro-smudger for softening lines, but its sharpener is separate. LushLine+ builds the sharpener in and lays down full colour in a single glide, so there's less to carry and less to fuss with.
LushLine+ winsShade range
Credit where it's due — PrimeEyes offers a wider, more playful shade range including metallics and shimmers. If variety is your priority, this is where it shines. LushLine+ keeps to well-edited core shades.
PrimeEyes winsFormula & eye-kindness
PrimeEyes is hypoallergenic and pH-balanced; LushLine+ leans into nourishing, conditioning ingredients. Both are thoughtful choices for sensitive eyes, so it comes down to preference.
A close drawPrice & guarantee
One-time, LushLine+ is $26.00 against PrimeEyes' $28.00 — close on a like-for-like basis. The gap widens with a subscription ($22.10) or a multi-buy bundle, and LushLine+ is backed by a 100% money-back guarantee versus PrimeEyes' 30-day window.
LushLine+ winsThe two eyeliners in full
LushLine+ Waterproof Eyeliner
Pros
- Specifically for mature eyes
- Smudge-proof & waterproof
- Gentle on sensitive eyes
- Nourishes as it defines
- Easy, mess-free application
- Built-in sharpener
- 100% Money Back Guarantee
Cons
- Core shade range (fewer novelty shades)
- Best price only with subscription
PrimeEyes Glide Eyeliner
Pros
- Easy, precise application
- Hypoallergenic & ophthalmologist tested
- Water-resistant & smudge-resistant
- Wide, buildable shade range
- Includes a pro-smudger tool
Cons
- Water-resistant, not fully waterproof
- Can need multiple layers for depth
- Some smudging on lower lash line
- Separate sharpener (not built in)
- Higher price point
Why women switch to LushLine+
After testing the most-searched eyeliners for mature eyes, LushLine+ delivered the smooth, smudge-free definition of a premium liner — with all-day staying power and a gentler price.
Shop LushLine+- Truly waterproofSurvives tears, sweat & rain — not just light splashes
- Won't budge on hooded or crepey lidsNo transfer to the upper crease through the day
- Built-in sharpenerAlways a crisp point — no extra tools to carry or lose
- Kind to sensitive eyesConditions lashes & lids as it defines
- Better valueFrom $22.10 with subscription & bundle savings
- 100% money-back guaranteeLove it or your money back — zero risk to try
See LushLine+ on real, mature eyes
Frequently asked questions
Is LushLine+ really better than PrimeEyes Glide?+
In our wear tests, LushLine+ lasted longer and resisted water rather than just splashes, held up better on hooded and oily lids, and cost less. PrimeEyes is still a lovely liner — especially for its shade range — but for everyday all-day wear, LushLine+ was our pick.
What do PrimeEyes Glide Eyeliner reviews say?+
Across PrimeEyes Glide Eyeliner reviews and Prime Prometics eyeliner reviews, shoppers praise smooth application and shade range; the most common complaints are smudging on the lower lash line and that the Prime glide eyeliner is water-resistant rather than fully waterproof. In our own side-by-side test, LushLine+ outlasted the Prime Prometics eyeliner for all-day, waterproof wear.
What's the real difference between the two?+
The biggest difference is longevity. PrimeEyes Glide is water-resistant, while LushLine+ is fully waterproof, so it stays put through sweat, tears and rain. LushLine+ also has a built-in sharpener and a lower price, while PrimeEyes offers a wider shade range and a separate pro-smudger tool.
Is LushLine+ actually waterproof?+
Yes. Unlike water-resistant liners that soften with moisture, LushLine+ is formulated to stay put — our testers wore it through workouts and hot showers with no smudging or transfer to the crease.
Can I wear LushLine+ on hooded or sensitive eyes?+
It's designed specifically for mature and hooded eyes, and its conditioning formula is gentle enough for sensitive eyes. It won't drag on crepey lids or transfer up into the crease as the day goes on.
Is there a money-back guarantee?+
Yes — LushLine+ is backed by a 100% money-back guarantee, so you can try it completely risk-free. PrimeEyes offers a 30-day money-back window by comparison.
How do I get the best price?+
The lowest price on LushLine+ comes with a flexible subscription, and you can stack further savings by buying a bundle. You're never locked in — subscriptions can be adjusted or cancelled anytime.
From pro artists to everyday women
See how LushLine+ delivers smooth, smudge-proof definition across every eye shape.
Make the switch to the liner that actually lasts all day
PrimeEyes Glide is a lovely liner if shade variety is your priority. But if you want a liner that truly stays put through the day, feels kind on sensitive lids, and costs less to keep buying — LushLine+ by Rumi Cosmetiques came out on top in every wear test.
Get The #1-Rated EyelinerThis is an independent, advertising-supported comparison created to help shoppers evaluate their options. We may receive compensation when you purchase through links on this page, which supports our testing. Opinions and test findings are our own. "PrimeEyes Glide", "Prime Prometics" (PrimePrometics), "LushLine+" and "Rumi Cosmetiques" are trademarks of their respective owners; this page is not affiliated with or endorsed by Prime Prometics. Product prices, formulations and guarantees are accurate to the best of our knowledge at the time of testing and may change — always check the retailer's site for current details.